Ok - I was leaning towards SnpEff was an ANNOVAR alternative, but I wanted to see what other people thought. It seems to provide a lot of additional and potentially useful information, so that is also a plus.
For humans, it looks like there is an hg19 SnpEff database, but I don't see either mm9 or mm10 for mouse. For both human and mouse, there are NCBI-based databases, but they seem pretty specific. For example, I have a mm9 alignment. SnpEff has databases for NCBIM37.64, NCBIM37.65, and NCBIM37.66.
Do you know which one most precisely matches UCSC mm9?