There are many times on this site where direct (perhaps even real time) communication between moderators or regular users would prove beneficial, such as:
- Handling spam posts or otherwise problematic users
- Dealing with site issues
- Ask for clarification about site norms
- Clarifying posts without producing pages worth of comments on posts
For such purposes I have created a slack for the biostars community, which you can access here.
Do not ask questions on slack that would otherwise be appropriate on biostars! Doing such multiple times can get you banned from slack (after a warning). Slack is meant as a convenient supplement for biostars, not a replacement.
This slack currently contains a general channel and a private "moderator-chat" channel. The latter is restricted access and meant only for those with moderator access here so they can discuss user issues privately (this is equivalent to the Teacher's Lounge on StackExchange, for those familiar with that). Just ping me to get added to this channel.
Please join us over on biostar.slack.com.
Please note that users in some countries may receive an error from Slack regarding being from an "embargoed country". I agree this is quite annoying, but something that Slack itself dictates. Currently the only country I know to be embargoed is Iran, but there may be others. For users in affected countries, please know that if you're able to get around the silly embargo that you're quite welcome to join the community (we're not going to discriminate against anyone based on the country they may be living/working in).
EDIT (by GenoMax ): If you are a moderator on Biostars then you're are encouraged to join the Biostar slack channel and then let one of the mods on slack know (most of us use the same names we use here) so you can be given access to mod-channel. Moderator-only channel has been extremely useful to coordinate moderation actions/get consensus on various issues to improve the overall quality of moderation on Biostars.
0 answers
No answers yet.
Log in to answer this question.
BTW, this is inspired by WouterDeCoster , who suggested something like this on Twitter.
I seem to get the following when following the link...
Not sure if I'm the only one
Oops, sorry, I put the wrong link in!
I tried the link; says that "It looks like you're in an embargoed country".
https://ibb.co/dFJrUc
Well that's a new one. Are you accessing from Iran?
Yes, I tried the link from Iran
I don't know if this is due to the US-Iran political situation or the internet restrictions in Iran. If you have VPN access elsewhere or can use an open proxy then I imagine that could be used to circumvent this. I'll contact slack and ask them what's going on with this, though, since obviously it'd be better not to exclude people based on where they happened to be born or happen to live.
Thank you, I am googling to find something like VPN.
I suggest adding a ground rule. If whatever you are asking about exceeds 2-3 lines it needs to be in a Biostars post.
Sounds fair. My suggestion would be that questions can only be about an existing thread, or before posting. It is not meant to replace biostars. The purpose of biostars is to be searchable for future reference and for other users, moving question to a slack channel defeats all of that.
Would be fine for mod-discussions, meta questions,...
I'm in 100% agreement on this.
BTW, feel free to directly edit my post to add ground rules. The long-term hope is that the slack becomes completely moderator managed, so I won't become a BDFL. So other mods directly putting rules in would seem quite appropriate.
Can one ask her/his question and shares files with an online biostar in chat? Because if a biostar at that time enables to help, this would more time efficient than sharing a post here
Thank you
I really want to avoid people directly asking questions in the chat itself. The biostars site is indexed by google and posts don't disappear. Messages on the slack eventually disappear (I'm not paying for the per-user licenses needed to keep the whole history) and it's anyway not indexed by google. Sharing files would be OK as long as it's part of an iterative back and forth with people. Posts on biostars should be self-contained, with the chat serving as a convenient supplement only (e.g., it's a real PITA to constantly upload images to imgur or something, but easy to drop them into slack if you're having a discussion with someone and need go through 20 iterations of plots). Ideally any final results of discussions in slack that center on a post on biostar will end up back in biostar. In short, slack is fleeting, biostars is permanent.
is this link still active: biostar.slack.com ? Devon Ryan
I thought so, but if it's not working for you then I'll make a new link.
Thanks @ Devon Ryan. It is not working as of now. PFA image.
I am getting the same error message.
I was recommended to join by another moderator - if this is still active, can you please check what is needed for new people to participate?
Can you try this: https://join.slack.com/t/biostar/shared_invite/enQtNTE1ODA0OTU3MTM2LTQ5MzY1Mjg0ZDdmYTZhNTRmMmU2Mjg4ZGI0NmNiZWNhOTUxNmE5MzU4ZjU3MjA0OWQxMGZlODdmZTUzNTI3NTg
Yes - that works!
Maybe I need to understand slack more, but it seems like the topics cover more than just moderation guidelines (and, if slack requires you to be invited to view the content, I think it is extremely important that these sort of conversations be public - so, I don't think that slack is as appropriate for general troubleshooting, but I do respect wanting to avoid having hurt feelings about sensitive topics).
However, thank you very much for organizing that!
Ok - I can answer my own question now (for other interested people):
You also need a 2nd invite (to moderator-chat-work). I agree this can be a useful way to have discussions.
Thanks again for all of your help!
Devon Ryan My account is deactivated at my behest. Could you please reactivate it?
Done