The FASTQ file that is giving the errors was generated from Kneaddata to remove human data from the dataset (we are doing a metagenomics analysis.) When uploading the original FASTQ file, no header issues are given.
I don't have to use Kneaddata for removal of the human contamination using a reference genome. But it seemed easier than using an aligner, removing the unmapped BAM and converting to a FASTQ file (I also feel like this would give FASTQ issues as well.)
I think the part that is causing problems may be the asterisks [*] rather than what you indicated. It is normal that headers have different numbering, but asterisks are what to my eye is inconsistent.
The last two numbers in the read name are xy coordinates on the flow cell tile...they absolutely are supposed to be different for every read.