This is a test version of Biostars. For the public version, visit https://www.biostars.org.
Multiple-Sequence Alignment Trimming

I want to construct a phylogenetic tree based on 5 housekeeping loci from two different Vibrio spp. Reviewing the literature, it is a generally accepted practice that the 5 loci are concatenated before multiple sequence alignments. After multiple sequence alignments it is also show that alignment trimming is performed in order to remove necessary gaps and regions that are not conserved. I have found an alignment trimming tool called trimal. I was wondering if anyone has used this and why would it not be better to simply use a program like MEGA and use the complete-deletion option where sites missing data or alignments gaps are removed before phylogenetic tree construction? Isn't the option in MEGA essentially the same thing as trimming?.. what are the benefits and drawbacks of both? Any help would be appreciated Thanks.

-Tony

sequence alignment assembly
• 11,507 views • link
updated by Ram Ram • written by tony • tony

1 answer

I'm probably late with the answer, but I'll leave it anyway. The answer is No.

As far as I remember (I used MEGA only on classes during my bachelor studies, and never after) this option removes all gaps which is the same as de-aligning.

TrimAL removes whole columns, that are poorly aligned, or have a lot of gaps, leaving rest of the alignment as it was.

If you do some phylo go for TrimAL, or Guidance. This is a "tool for the job". You wouldn't use a spoon to drive the nail if you have hammer, right?

• 0 views • link
written by michau • michau

Log in to answer this question.

More posts like this